I have a hard time believing that some emptiers were 'accidental' or 'coding oversights', whilst many definitely fit that scenario I agree, for my money an awful lot don't.
(So the old Wild West emptier, where they knobbed up the £15 upgrade and allowed 2 x £7.60 on the Super Cash Duel feature, which makes £15.20 (illegal win), rounds up to £16, knocks the pound off, £15 banked, free win - that makes sense as a coding error.)
But off the top of my head how do you explain something like Supercharged? That it's a 'debug' routine that just happens to trigger the top feature if you press a certain combination of buttons?
Or going back further how about the way JPMs 'numbered', so the fact they only showed 1/12 when they had a jackpot in them was accidental somehow?
What about Fairground where the Coconut Shy 'trick' appeared on the £8 ROMs? (Doesn't work on the £6 ROMs.) You hold down three specific buttons in order and then press START multiple times to get a guaranteed jackpot on what can be a £1/£2 no-skill feature, so the machine doesn't block it at all. That's an accident or an error?
Thinking about it many do make sense as accidents/errors, or indeed players finding a way around the compensators and suchlike. For example the 'knockback method' on machines like Psycho Cash Beast and Lotta Luck were clearly driving the compensators haywire, many JPM/ACE machines responded to genuine skill and understanding how to take the value out of them, and if you could hit Stop N Step on something like Cashbuster, happy days.
Then there are some that are in a kind of grey area. BWB's video poker game Red Hot Poker, where you play one credit at a time until you get a £3/£6 repeater win, once achieved, let it cycle round the attract mode three times, and when it's on the attract mode screen with the '2' card showing, put a credit in and you get the '2' to (no-lose) gamble your win on, irrespective of the card you had when you got the win. Repeat until empty.
Indeed BWB's MPU4 video games had all kinds of sketchy stuff on them, either those guys made LOTS of mistakes, or something dodgy was going on.
Edited by Chopaholic, 29 October 2017 - 07:24 AM.